They are both doing well, but the one in the grow bag is much smaller. It is unclear whether it is because of the grow bag, because this one took a day longer to germinate. What I do like about the grow bag is that it is pretty much impossible to overwater, but what I don't like is the soil dries quickly near the edges and when I water, the water seeps out of the sides a lot rather than moisten the soil at the sides. I wonder if this will affect root growth long term.