the carbon filters you get have drastically different quality differences. If they give the mass of activated carbon, that's the best way to compare.
also, must make sure the carbon filters recommended CFM is matched properly to your duct fan... usually if it's the same size, this is fine, but should not assum.. 4"er is probably 170cfm max give or take, and the carbon filter should say something similar.
good carbon filters will eliminate most smell. Negative pressure in the grow area is key for it to be most effective, otherwise you have leaks of stinky air not exiting through the exhaust duct/filter. If you exhaust outside the room that should create negative pressure.