Maybe, the glossiness of the plastic underneath? The leaves contort like that toward light, so a glossy/mirror-like refelction might be tricking the leaves. The extra 15-20% might be enough to cause it but previous levels are not.
bottom line is leaves contort like that because they are turning toward stronger light.
Now, do you need more power or just giving more? 35-40 DLI is all you want. A plant can handle more than that by reducing pigmentation or it may take a long time to show some damage symptoms. Essentially, giving more either damages the plant or results in an adaptation to use less light in the leaves. There's no circumventing the limitation without extra CO2 and a well-controlled environment.
if your light specs are accurate -- far from a given as most manufactures fib -- make use of a DLI table with hours of operation and see if that 15-20% extar is a good thing or detrimental
Too much light is definitely a possibility. this could rule it out. Usually if light is too strong, it causes top-most leaves to show symptoms first. I think this is something tricking the leaves with a beam of reflected light or something.