Dealing with fungus gnats in a living soil setup can be frustrating, but since you caught it early while your plants are still in early veg, you can knock them out pretty easily without harming your soil biology.
Here are the most effective, organic methods to get rid of them quickly:
1. The Quickest Fix: Mosquito Bits or Mosquito Dunks (Bti)
This is the gold standard for living soil growers because it targets the larvae without disrupting your beneficial microbes.
* What it is: Bacillus thuringiensis israelensis (Bti)—a naturally occurring bacterium that kills gnat larvae when they eat it, but is completely safe for plants, pets, and earthworms.
* How to use it: Soak a handful of Mosquito Bits in your watering can for a few hours (or overnight) to create a tea, then water your plants with it. Alternatively, sprinkle the bits directly onto the topsoil before watering. Reapply every time you water until the gnats are gone.
2. Physical Barrier: Perlite or Sand Top Dressings
Gnats need the top layer of soil to stay moist so they can lay eggs. If you cut off their access, they can't reproduce.
* How to use it: Add a 1/2-inch layer of coarse builder's sand or dry perlite completely covering the top of your soil. Keep the surface dry, and the gnats will quickly die off because they can't burrow in to lay eggs or escape.
3. Catch the Adults: Yellow Sticky Traps
While Bti and top dressings handle the larvae in the soil, you still need to deal with the flying adults laying more eggs.
* How to use it: Place bright yellow sticky cards right at the soil line or stick them in your pots. Adult gnats are attracted to the color yellow and get trapped instantly, breaking the breeding cycle.
4. Backup Support: Beneficial Nematodes (Steinernema feltiae)
If the infestation is stubborn, you can introduce microscopic beneficial nematodes. They hunt down and eat gnat larvae in the soil. Just mix them into your water and apply to the pots.
A Quick Tip for Living Soil:
Cut back slightly on watering frequency if your soil is staying too wet between waterings—letting the top couple of inches dry out completely will make your pots much less hospitable to future gnat generations.