Chat
RecommendedRecommended

My very first grow. RIP: PH issue. โœž โœž

1
9
12
209
a year ago
Follow
1
FarmBox Standard 180cm x 80cm x 80cm
Indoor
Room Type
Monkey Pro Light Mix
Grow medium
14 l
Pot Size
Grow Conditions
Week 2
Vegetation
8
cm
inch
Height
18 hrs
Light Schedule
8+ conditions after
Login
Nutrients
ml/l
ml/gal
tsp/gal
Commented by
HakunaMatata HakunaMatata
a year ago
After almost 3 weeks of stunted growth I've decided to stop here and start over. But not after trying to understand what happened. I believe it was a PH issue since the stem is violet, leaves are droopy and lime green, and the roots show no sign of rotting. -- Thanks for the comments :) I suspected it may be due to overwatering but I dont know, I didnt water the plant for almost 5 days in a row and it didn't improve either. Anyway, its easier for me to start over, try to understand as best as I can what happened and yeah. Also, I think its valuable to learn that an experienced grower believes the plant could have thrived. So, yeah, next time ill push through it.
Similar Diaries
Thc-victory first grow
4 weeks
Thc-victory first groweremiita
THC-Victory
3 minutes ago ยท 2 comments
LSD Barney's Farm
1 weeks
LSD Barney's Farmyungdanktwanog
LSD-Feminsed
12 minutes ago
Dankberry ANS
9 weeks
Dankberry ANSXII_XII_MrGreen
Dankberry
13 days ago ยท 48 comments
Green Gelato Auto
11 weeks
Green Gelato Autogreen_grow
Green Gelato Automatic
2 months ago ยท 1 comment
Black Orchid Auto - Zamnesia - B&B
11 weeks
Black Orchid Auto - Zamnesia - B&BBread_n_Buds
Black Orchid Automatic
6 days ago ยท 32 comments
Galactic Grape Auto
13 weeks
Galactic Grape AutoDabking
Galactic Grape Auto
2 days ago ยท 8 comments
Another Sip Please - Pinot Noir
5 weeks
Another Sip Please - Pinot NoirTheopen
Illuminauto #44 - Pinot Noir
a month ago ยท 1 comment
Purple Haze Auto - Zamnesia - B&B
11 weeks
Purple Haze Auto - Zamnesia - B&BBread_n_Buds
Purple Haze Automatic
6 days ago ยท 18 comments
Grow Questions
HakunaMatata
HakunaMatatastarted grow question a year ago
3 weeks of not growing -> Autopsy: Stem is violet, roots I believe they look healthy (no rotting, maybe im wrong?), and leaves are droopy and lime green. Was a PH issue maybe? (I'll plant new seeds and get a PH meter for this next grow, i shouldn't have saved money on that)
Solved
Other. General questions
like
gottagrowsometime
gottagrowsometimeanswered grow question a year ago
Pour away from your stem it promotes roots growth. As they go searching for fluid and can feel moisture near and go in that area. Spread out and so on. Anyways. If you've any issues again. Try and push through it. As there was nothing wrong. And getting them through the seedling stage is the easy part. If you need help. Feel free to mes me or anyone here who respondz
Comments
Login

Show by Week
Sort by
popularity
popularity
newest
oldest
MalumProhibitum
MalumProhibitumweek 2
With pots that massive in comparison to the small seedling I'd be very careful and avoid giving too much water. Any over-watering will deprive the roots of oxygen for weeks and stunt the growth severly. Or you could go with the small peat-cube made for seedlings route. Transfer to bigger pot, once the seedling is bigger to give the plants more opportunity for root-gas-exchange and the soil dries up a lot faster. Good luck on your next grow! ๐Ÿ˜‹
MalumProhibitum
MalumProhibitum
@HakunaMatata,Yes Sir!!--๐Ÿ‘Š๐Ÿ˜Ž--Spot On! I've noticed a lot of ppl treat the nutrients like it was plant food, when in reality the "macro nutrients NPK, micro nutrients Ca, Mg, S and trace elements all combined added to the water just consists of a miniscule; less than 1โ€ฐ of what you are administering "feeding (!sic)" to your plant. Your goal is to stay somewhere in the lower than 0,25โ€ฐ nutrient to water weight the initial week for proper root development. Any pimping will just slow down the plants ability to process the basic nutrients; carbon, hydrogen and oxygen that is already avaliable to the plant in sufficient quantities simply through the air, soil and water. Also the roots arent very happy with too much H+ ions around em, so the closer to neutral the water is the first week, the better in my opinion, until week 1 veg is over and the plant is already developing it's 3:rd set of leaves. So unless your tap water is highly acidic or basic, adding pH down / up might actually delay the root develpment of the seedling, a phenomena easilly noticed by those poor bastards who get chlorosis etc the first week from too much "care" when regular tap-water on some other plant in depleted, neutral pH soil would look fine the first week. The real food is the actual water (H2O), the content in the air (Oxygen+Carbon dioxide), then a huge portion the light (photons) pushing the process forward. This in combination with the excess of what the seedling needs, already stored in the seedling itself from seed has made me draw the conclusion that the less effort you put in the grow the first week, the better the outcome. Probably why paper-towel tecnique works so good, yet the seedling might die as it's roots gets burned when being transferred from the moist paper to the hot & pimped-soil, with excess of nutrients, love and what not. I've also noticed how much better the small plants grow, the lower the TDS is in the soil, and how a subtle move, like adding a teaspoon of wet-used-cofee-grounds added as top-dressing to the seedling used in good faith might delay the root development and leave its roots severly stunted and behind in development in comparison to her seedling-sisters, just given neutral water the first week. First week --Less is more.
HakunaMatata
HakunaMatata
@MalumProhibitum, whoa!! thanks for the info, I really appreaciate it!!!! I was feeling a bit down after killing the Blueberry so yeah, thanks for taking the time to write such a detailed comment! I potted the blueberry on a Monkey Light Mix Pro. The Tangie was potted on a custom soil. The custom soil seems to be more aireated than the Light Mix. I actually thought i made a mistake when making the custom soil because i felt it didn't have much water retention, and I thought the Monkey Light Mix Pro was better (surely in terms of nutrients is better balanced). However, after a couple of waterings I realized the the Mix wasn't drying at all, the top first inch was drying but the rest of the soil was extremely moist, not swamped though. So I kept watering thinking that was the expected behavior of the mix... Now I think I know what to look for in terms of watering. Probably I can use that monkey light mix but following your advice and mixing with coco. This is key -> "the bigger the pot, the more coco, to compensate for the decreased area to volume ratio of big containers"
MalumProhibitum
MalumProhibitum
@HakunaMatata, Yes, autos are a bit more delicate when it comes to development before flower and any changes along the way might affect the harvest in a negative way whereas regular seeds you have the opportunity to extend veg if things goes sideways and can switch to 12/12 whenever you think the grow-room is populated and plants are ready for flower. I think I'd stick with what other ppl recommended and go for one pot, but you could keep the watering in check and there are few tricks to avoid drowning the poor plant ๐Ÿ˜ I had same issues too with watering too much until I started adding a dishcloth to the bottom of the pot, and made 4x finger sized holes for the corners to peek through, and then added another 4x dishcloth on the outside to passivly suck out and absorb any excess water (lowers the time to recover and soil to get an apropriate water-content within 3-4 days if I overwater instead of months, when I start a seedling in a 30liter++ pot)๐Ÿ˜œ Then I just squeeze out any excess water gathering in the dishcloths and remove them when they start to dry out and I know there isnt any abundance of water in the soil anymore. Some ppl want stones at the bottom, big coarse stuff, and I went the other route and added the cloth to be able to regulate the water content, then I add Coconut Coir to the soil to make the texture of the soil more airy, the bigger the pot, the more coco, to compensate for the decreased area to volume ratio of big containers. The soil is like a sponge with massive surface area and ability to exchange gasses, add too much water and the surface area in the soil decreases drasticly and you end up starving the roots of oxygen. If you starve the roots of oxygen, their development halts and within days they start to die, and as the roots is like a mirror image of how the development above the soil is, you want big roots. Try get a feel for the weight of the pots and let the top layer dry out some atleast before adding more water. You want moist soil, not a swamp ๐Ÿ˜‚ Your diary -BSF Tangie XXL Auto- looks promising ๐Ÿ‘Š๐Ÿ˜Š--๐Ÿ€
Load more (1)
mrmateo
mrmateoweek 1
same thing happened to mine only i was growing in coco realized i forgot to add perlite and forgot to buffer the coco..... i transplanted into new coco buffered with perlite and hope it fixes my problem or i'm doing the same as you, one time i also had a cheap ph pen with a low battery reading the wrong ph lucky i figured that one out to save the grow๐Ÿ˜
HakunaMatata
HakunaMatata
@@mrmateo, great you managed to save that one! Yeah I agree. And probably in the next couple of grows Iโ€™ll try coco or living soil. I think what was confusing for me here is that the bag of Monkey Light Mix is advertised as already balanced in nutes, composition and water retention. So I didnโ€™t expect to have the need to add stuff to it. I explicitly bought that mix as a beginner because I didnโ€™t fully understand how the plant behaves and all the possible substrates. Iโ€™m on a second grow now on the same soil and the same symptoms appeared. And while now I think I understand how to fix it, Iโ€™m certainly not happy on how the brand advertises this mix.
love_2_grow
love_2_growweek 0
Happy Growing, Buddy! ๐ŸŒฑ๐ŸŒฑ๐ŸŒฑ
love_2_grow
love_2_grow
@HakunaMatata, Thank you, and I'm happy if you find something useful. Just buzz me if you have any questions.
HakunaMatata
HakunaMatata
@love_2_grow, thanks man! Had a quick look at some of your diaries; Great info and awesome results, i'll take a couple of ideas from them.
Terp1
Terp1week 0
good luck ๐Ÿ’ช๐Ÿ˜Ž
HakunaMatata
HakunaMatataweek 2
This was a PH issue after all. Soil is measuring almost 8. Note for every beginner, get yourself a PH meter, don't be cheap like me.