No two plants, even of the same strain, will have identical requirements.
The pale plant obviously has a hungrier appetite.
Just like people, you could have the same parents, but your brother/sister might like oysters but you yourself hate them, so it is with plants, what may be enough food for one plant, might leave the other one with an empty stomach.
Giving the pale plant a bit of extra nitrogen and it should green up soon enough.
Hope this helps, Organoman.