all feedings the same does not equate to all plants being the same. so, stop thinking like that.
if there is a difference in an indoor grow it could be what you do, it could be genetic, but that isn't relevant. just react to the different behaviour sooner.
almost certainly a toxicity, since others are healthy and you have fed consistently. Ease off for a while. hit the reset button and eliminate possiblities before dumping anything into soil.
doing everything the same will not guarantee the same results in the plant. so many factors the eye doesn't account for. so many things you have no idea you did dfferently, but did. even if anal about precision, which few are. Especially in soil. While it is a buffer for mistakes, it also is less micromangeable in regards to know exactly what its contents are for nutrients. microbes have their say that you cannot account for with common sense and an eyeball.