Chat
RecommendedRecommended

Overwatering or underwatering? Please help

PapaNugs
PapaNugsstarted grow question 2 years ago
Help needed if this is over or under watering. I did give her some water yesterday. Just a little. Possibly not giving enough? Or just too much?
Solved
Other. General questions
like
Cheeba_Inu
Cheeba_Inuanswered grow question 2 years ago
Hey there! That is a good question, and there are a few issues that complicate this case in my opinion. The advantage of coco is that it is very hard to over water, and it tends to provide ideal levels of air and water to the roots even with frequent waterings. I have watered my coco 3 times a day on a number of grows without any signs of overwatering. When coco dries out, it can be more damaging to the plant than other mediums (the simplest It explanation is that becomes very "salty"). It looks like you have a fair amount of organic amendments added to the coco. The complication is that these organics can really weigh down the growing medium, causing it to hold onto more moisture while preventing air getting to the roots. It essentially eliminates a major benefit of coco as a growing medium. Right now the coco looks a bit dry, but also very dense which may create issues. But I can only say how the surface looks, and can't say how much moisture is deeper in the growing medium. A good way to judge over/under watering by lifting and feeling the weight of the pot. If it feels a bit light and is experiencing wilted leaves it's probably underwatered. If it still feels heavy with water then a lack of water would not be an issue. If I had to guess one way or another based on the photos, they need a full watering with plenty of runoff. If they droop within a few hours of this I would advise reporting them with plenty of perlite, chunk coir, or rice hulls to aerate the roots. Hope this helps, and and feel free to reach out if you have any questions! Happy growing!
2 likes
Complain
Selected By The Grower
PapaNugs
PapaNugsanswered grow question 2 years ago
It was underwatered. I appreciate and the love and answers. This group is the best!
like
Complain
Ezzjaybruh
Ezzjaybruhanswered grow question 2 years ago
Coco has enough aeration naturally that it’s near impossible to overwater. The red stems, not just petioles, but actual stems point towards deficiencies all around as well..
1 like
Complain
MonkeyMan
MonkeyMananswered grow question 2 years ago
The best way to tell with coco coir is to check the weight of the pot/plant. If it feels deceptively light then she needs a water. Personally I try and let the soil dry for a day then giver her a good water, the plants love it as the roots hate being damn all the time, it also stops gnats and other pests from living in your soil as these pests depend on a wet substrate to hatch their spawn.
1 like
Complain
GrowingGrannie
GrowingGrannieanswered grow question 2 years ago
Is this your Purple Punch grow? I'm going to assume it is... First and foremost, you're not watering it enough... you have to keep Coco Coir wet all the time... so your average daily water (.4 gallons in a 5 gallon pot at this age!) is far too little. Along with the drooping, the red stems are telling me this is really stressed out - and I think I'm also seeing some signs of nitrogen toxicity... Your nutes are a strange choice for growing weed... you aren't growing vegetables or roses ... your vegetable nutes and the bat guano are delivering far too much nitrogen for weed at this stage of life... and the amount of Potassium and Phosphorus is certainly not enough even when you combine all the various nutes you're providing - eventually, you're going to start seeing deficiencies of these very important nutes. And finally, I'm not seeing any information on the pH levels you're maintaining... are you measuring this? Are you getting any runoff when you give plain water and are you testing THAT for its pH level? When you give plain water, you need to give enough that there is about 10-20% runoff - this helps clear out excess nutes and salts - and you need to water/feed generously every 1-2 days - Coco is/should be like doing hydro in "soil." I would suggest looking for different nutes... search this site for grows done in Coco Coir and look at some of the really successful grows - see what nutes they're using, message the growers for THEIR recommendations - or put up another question here asking the general community what nutes they would suggest for Coco grows... then do some research and find a line you feel comfortable trying out. Meanwhile, start letting these ladies have a decent size drink... and until you find/decide to use different nutes, at least get rid of the bat guano as it is the one piece of your nute program that is giving far too much nitrogen... Good luck!
1 like
Complain
NobodysBuds
NobodysBudsanswered grow question 2 years ago
looks like very dry coco. best way to judge is by the weight of the pot (easy to be consistent this way). allowing surface to suprficially dry is about as far as you want to take coco. if you have 70/30 mix of perlite it'd be nearly impossible to ovewater with volume. as long as enough "dryback" occurs, you won't overwater coco due to frequency. ovewatering.. either frequency or too much in one sitting -- one will cause weird symptoms in leaves, the other will cause it to droop like crazy as long as the roots are deprived of O2.. never sure which ppl mean by overwatering, but knowing the cause and effect of each is better than knowing the vocabulary. this doesn't look like it fits either description. amendments? so not a full soilless grow? usually you'd fertilize with each irigation with 10-15% runoff, which maintains concentration of nutes in substrate... with a proper amount of perlite mixed in and properly sized container, you can even do frequent irrigations per day without any issues. you need enough dryback to occur, so you end up with slightly smaller pots and definitely would need an automated system due to labor involved, but this would match or nearly match the best hydro setups. irrigating with more dryback will have great results too, no worries.. and i'd recommend learning that first before taking that next step. (and, you may be going in totally different direction with amendments and maybe some sort of living soil type thing? an equally cool way to grow for different reasons)
1 like
Complain
PapaNugs
PapaNugsanswered grow question 2 years ago
Using Coco coir. Just added amendments and transplanted.
like
Complain
Ezzjaybruh
Ezzjaybruhanswered grow question 2 years ago
What kinda soil you using? It looks problematic.. looks very dense and clay-ey..
1 like
Complain
Similar Grow Questions
Solved
MrMoMoGroW
MrMoMoGroW
Harvest time?Is ready or not?🧐
Week 13
Other. General questions
4 years ago
5
3
Solved
Statman
Statman
Crescita pianteCome mai non crescono?
Week 1
Other. General questions
4 years ago
5
2