No, I can’t say that it will be less productive. It should be way better than HID. But changing light in the middle of flowering is risky imho. Your girls got used to current spectrum, they love it. This is the most important source of energy for them. I would just add one LED if it has a dimmer, and started using both LED+HPS. But only in case where heat build up is not an issue. I am seriously thinking of adding low wattage HPS into my future grow ;)