Hey Buddy that’s a really good observation and you’re absolutely right: manufacturer distance charts are only a starting point, not a rule.
Those recommendations assume “average” conditions, but plants don’t grow in averages. Cultivar, health, environment, and growth stage all change how much light a plant can actually use.
This is where PPFD matters.
⸻
Why PPFD matters more than distance
Lamp distance doesn’t tell you how much usable light the plant is receiving — PPFD does. Two setups can have the same distance and deliver very different light levels depending on:
• Fixture efficiency
• Lens / diode layout
• Reflectivity of the space
• Plant height and canopy shape
PPFD measures what the plant actually receives at canopy level.
⸻
Signs I look for to dial it in (without instruments)
Plants will tell you a lot if you watch closely:
Signs light is too intense:
• Leaves praying hard, then flattening or taco-ing
• Tips bleaching or turning pale
• Upper leaves feeling dry or stiff
• Slower growth despite “good” conditions
Signs light is too weak:
• Stretching internodes
• Leaves staying flat or drooping
• Lower sites losing vigor
• Plant looks healthy but underperforms
Signs it’s dialed in:
• Consistent, relaxed praying
• Healthy green new growth
• Tight internodes (for that cultivar)
• Strong side branching
• Steady metabolism (water + nutrient uptake)
That “happy praying” posture is one of the best visual indicators.
⸻
Why cultivars react differently
Different genetics have different:
• Leaf thickness
• Chlorophyll density
• Metabolic speed
• Heat and light tolerance
Some cultivars want high PPFD and thrive under it. Others hit saturation earlier and get stressed if pushed the same way. That’s why distance charts can’t be universal.
⸻
About measuring PPFD (game changer)
If you don’t already measure PPFD, it’s worth considering.
A proper PPFD meter:
• Removes guesswork
• Helps you repeat results
• Makes dialing in much faster
• Lets you adapt light to each cultivar instead of forcing the plant to adapt
They’re not cheap, but they’re getting more accessible — and once you use one, it’s hard to go back to guessing by distance alone.
Even knowing “rough zones” (veg vs flower PPFD ranges) helps tremendously.
⸻
Big picture
PPFD isn’t about maxing numbers — it’s about matching light intensity to the plant’s ability to use it.
Environment, temperature, CO₂, nutrition, root health — they all determine how much light a plant can handle. Light is just one piece of the system, but it’s a powerful one when understood.
You’re already doing the most important part: watching the plant instead of blindly following charts. PPFD just gives you a clearer language for what the plant is telling you 🌱
Growers Love my friend and my apologies for the long reply but i felt this one needed a proper explanation 💚💚💚