Chat
RecommendedRecommended

Garden hose filter

SoloDog86
SoloDog86started grow question 4 months ago
I was looking at buying a garden hose filter to remove the chloramine and chlorine. I'm worried it will remove the cal, mag, exc... Anyone have any input into this.
Solved
Feeding. Chemical composition
like
Polyphemus
Polyphemusanswered grow question 4 months ago
the chlorine / chloramine in your water is not high enough to cause any negative effect. Chlorine wil absolutely dissipate quickly -- light will break it down very fast, ask anyone that owns a pool. you'd do better leaving it out on a sunny day on back deck for 3-4 hours then leaving it out 24h in your basement.. could be wrong but i bet it's damn close. Sun absolutely catalyzes teh gassing off of Cl-2 (elemental Cl). Chloramine will not gas off easily. Leaving water with chloramine out for 2-3 days won't do shit. What's worse is stagnating your water for 48-72h. Whatever positive getting rid of minute amounts of chlorine/chloramine will be far offset by the negatives of leavinag water standing around for 2-3 days. Even if you put bubblers in or something that stirs the water. the ppm of mg and ca in your water won't be so large that a minor adjusment to your fertilizer can't fix. if you do want to filter the water, you may just need to boost whichever component of your fertilizer has the most Ca in it without putting anything else out of balance. i do things they say you shouldn't, lol, like using softened water. I switched a few years ago. My unsoftened water is 300ppm or higher. I didn't need any adgjustment in my formula since that switch. I lost some portion of Ca/Mg for sure with very hard water but it must not have been large enough in proportion to what my feed adds. YMMV. Keep notes and adjust as necessary. This is a trial and error context.. nobody wil be able to tell you for certain given all the variables at play that differ from one house/region to the next in regard to water. RV filters, garden hose filters.. some cheap ones are out there... no idea how reliable they are. might only reudce 1/4-1/2 of dissolved minerals, i'd wager. Need an RO system to do it right. try i.. do one pot with your OCD behaviours and one whre you don't care.. prefereably clones so you don't wrongly attribute what was really caused by a slower growing plant to 'chlorine.' Its the same thing with the people who think flouride int eh water has some negative effect onthe human body. Not while we live eto 80-100 years, anyway, lol.. maybe if we start livign 150-200 years we'll have to revisit that question. Same with potted plants. Maybe, a mother plant that stays in the same pot forever is a different context, but a 4-6 month long grow cycle won't matter.
AsNoriu
AsNoriuanswered grow question 4 months ago
Some chlorines which are used now in mains need 72 hours or more. Old bubling for 24 is outdated. Fact.
like
Complain
AsNoriu
AsNoriuanswered grow question 4 months ago
1 like
Complain
AutoflowersSucK
AutoflowersSucKanswered grow question 4 months ago
Read the municipal water report on your local city website. They will have a complete report on % of whats in it. Look at your filter spec's and see what it filters out. If your worried about chlorine just fill containers and let them sit for 24 hours to off gas the chlorine. If your intention is to use it for outdoor garden watering, i would save your money and just use the hose water unflitered.
like
Complain
SoloDog86
SoloDog86answered grow question 4 months ago
Vitamin C Crystals. How much would you add to a 5-gal bucket?
like
Complain
SoloDog86
SoloDog86answered grow question 4 months ago
Thanks. The tap water I use has a ph of 8.2. I'll just let it sit and bubble it for 24hrs instead of wasting the money on a filter.
like
Complain
m0use
m0useanswered grow question 4 months ago
There is so little chloramine and chlorine in municipal water it does not matter in the long run. With chloramine you can naturalize it with a bit of Vit C in the water and let it sit for 12hrs With chlorine if you let it sit out it will mostly evaporate out. But again, its in such low concentrations it does not matter, I have used tap water for all my grows and never have I had an issue with any of the common disinfectants in the water. Most filters that remove that stuff are activated carbon and they don't really remove minerals, plus they clog up fast, I also don't know if it even has a good rate of removing the chloramine and chlorine Good Luck!
1 like
Complain
Similar Grow Questions
Solved
MiyamotoMusashi
MiyamotoMusashi
Hello growers, i would like to know whats the best tap water to feed to plants.
Feeding. Chemical composition
Feeding. Other
3 years ago
1