Hi
@Jocolope! This looks like over-watering to me. Your medium looks very wet, my guess is that roots/seedling are suffocating, drowned in water. It's very important for roots to alternance between wet & dry phases, this cycle will help roots to spread (searching for water). Now as a solution, I would let the medium dry, help it by putting a fan blowing a slight continuous breeze onto the container, maybe transplant with fresh medium in a bigger container, take it easy on the waterings (wet/dry cycle) and see how it goes in a few days. Hope this will help, keep us up-to-date and happy growing 👊